What's In My Jar

e.l.f. Cosmetics Putty Eye Primer Dupes

We found no close formula dupe for e.l.f. Cosmetics Putty Eye Primer. The nearest product, Peter Thomas Roth Skin To Die For Darkness-Reducing Under-Eye Treatment Eye Primer, is only a 31% match: it shares 3 of the original's 6 key ingredients (Dimethicone, Polymethylsilsesquioxane and Titanium dioxide).

Match % combines shared ingredients, the first five ingredients, shared actives and hero ingredients, irritancy (lower counts in the alternative's favour), texture and body area. Only products in the same routine step are compared.

e.l.f. Cosmetics Putty Eye Primer

e.l.f. Cosmetics

Putty Eye Primer

High irritancy Score: 75/100

What it is: Primer with 6 key ingredients
Works for: Moisturizing

View Product Search Another

20 alternatives found · Best match: 31% (Low)

View:

No close formula dupes found

These are the closest alternatives based on WIMJ's similarity score. Consider filtering by irritancy or ingredients you want to avoid.

Top dupes for e.l.f. Cosmetics Putty Eye Primer

Peter Thomas Roth Skin To Die For Darkness-Reducing Under-Eye Treatment Eye Primer

Peter Thomas Roth

Skin To Die For Darkness-Reducing Under-Eye Treatment Eye Primer

31%

Low match

Medium irritancy

3/7

key actives shared

24%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Isododecane Polymethylsilsesquioxane Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasSqualane Copernicia cerifera wax Isopropyl myristate
Unlike the original, it hasPalmitoyl tetrapeptide-7 Palmitoyl oligopeptide Hydrolyzed collagen
It also works for:Anti-agingEvens skin toneAnti-oxidation

See Peter Thomas Roth Skin To Die For Darkness-Reducing Under-Eye Treatment Eye Primer dupes View full product details

Laura Mercier Eye Basics Primer

Laura Mercier

Eye Basics Primer

30%

Low match

Medium irritancy

4/7

key actives shared

39%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Isododecane Copernicia cerifera wax Isopropyl myristate Ethylhexyl palmitate
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasPolymethylsilsesquioxane Squalane Dimethicone
Unlike the original, it hasCera alba Beeswax Copernicia cerifera cera

See Laura Mercier Eye Basics Primer dupes View full product details

Benefit Stay Don't Stray - Eye Primer

Benefit

Stay Don't Stray - Eye Primer

30%

Low match

Medium irritancy

3/7

key actives shared

33%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Isododecane Ethylhexyl palmitate Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasPolymethylsilsesquioxane Squalane Copernicia cerifera wax
Unlike the original, it hasMethicone Sodium hyaluronatevitamin C

See Benefit Stay Don't Stray - Eye Primer dupes View full product details

Marc Jacobs Beauty Under Perfecting Coconut Eye Primer

Marc Jacobs Beauty

Under Perfecting Coconut Eye Primer

30%

Low match

Medium irritancy

2/7

key actives shared

36%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Isododecane Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasPolymethylsilsesquioxane Squalane Copernicia cerifera wax
Unlike the original, it hasCyclopentasiloxane Trihydroxystearin Triethylhexanoin

See Marc Jacobs Beauty Under Perfecting Coconut Eye Primer dupes View full product details

Anastasia Beverly Hills Mini Eye Primer

Anastasia Beverly Hills

Mini Eye Primer

29%

Low match

Low irritancy

3/7

key actives shared

24%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Isododecane Polymethylsilsesquioxane Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasSqualane Copernicia cerifera wax Isopropyl myristate
Unlike the original, it hasPanthenol Cyclopentasiloxane Phenyl trimethicone
It also works for:Anti-aging

Buy at Ulta$16.00 $16.00as of 11/2 18:12 GMT

See Anastasia Beverly Hills Mini Eye Primer dupes View full product details

Rare Beauty Always An Optimist Weightless Eye Primer

Rare Beauty

Always An Optimist Weightless Eye Primer

29%

Low match

Low irritancy

2/7

key actives shared

27%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Isododecane Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasPolymethylsilsesquioxane Squalane Copernicia cerifera wax
Unlike the original, it hasGlycerin

Buy on Amazon$21.00 · as of 11/1 21:42 GMT

See Rare Beauty Always An Optimist Weightless Eye Primer dupes View full product details

BECCA Anti-Fatigue Under Eye Primer

BECCA

Anti-Fatigue Under Eye Primer

28%

Low match

Medium irritancy

2/7

key actives shared

18%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Polymethylsilsesquioxane Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasIsododecane Squalane Copernicia cerifera wax
Unlike the original, it hasAcetyl tetrapeptide-5 Cera microcristallina Sodium hyaluronate
It also works for:Anti-agingAnti-oxidation

See BECCA Anti-Fatigue Under Eye Primer dupes View full product details

Tula Face Filter Blurring & Moisturizing Primer

Tula

Face Filter Blurring & Moisturizing Primer

22%

Low match

Medium irritancy

4/7

key actives shared

39%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Isododecane Polymethylsilsesquioxane Ethylhexyl palmitate Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasSqualane Copernicia cerifera wax Isopropyl myristate
Unlike the original, it hasPhytosphingosine Lactic acid Vitamin e
It also works for:Anti-oxidationEvens skin toneExfoliationAnti-aging

Buy on Amazon$38.00 · as of 11/2 21:13 GMT

See Tula Face Filter Blurring & Moisturizing Primer dupes View full product details

THE ROUTE The Girlfriend - Skin-Loving Glow Primer

THE ROUTE

The Girlfriend - Skin-Loving Glow Primer

21%

Low match

Medium irritancy

3/7

key actives shared

24%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Polymethylsilsesquioxane Squalane Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasIsododecane Copernicia cerifera wax Isopropyl myristate
Unlike the original, it hasAcetyl hexapeptide-8 N-prolyl palmitoyl tripeptide-56 acetate Ceramide np
It also works for:ExfoliationEvens skin toneAnti-aging

Buy at Ulta$50.00 Amazon

See THE ROUTE The Girlfriend - Skin-Loving Glow Primer dupes View full product details

FENTY BEAUTY by Rihanna Pro Filt'r Instant Retouch Primer

FENTY BEAUTY by Rihanna

Pro Filt'r Instant Retouch Primer

21%

Low match

Medium irritancy

3/7

key actives shared

30%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Isododecane Polymethylsilsesquioxane Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasSqualane Copernicia cerifera wax Isopropyl myristate
Unlike the original, it hasSodium hyaluronate Glycerin

Buy on Amazon$40.00 · as of 11/2 18:43 GMT

See FENTY BEAUTY by Rihanna Pro Filt'r Instant Retouch Primer dupes View full product details

Fenty beauty Pro Filt'r Instant Retouch Primer

Fenty beauty

Pro Filt'r Instant Retouch Primer

21%

Low match

Medium irritancy

3/7

key actives shared

30%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Isododecane Polymethylsilsesquioxane Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasSqualane Copernicia cerifera wax Isopropyl myristate
Unlike the original, it hasSodium hyaluronate Glycerin

Buy on Amazon$40.00 · as of 11/2 18:33 GMT

See Fenty beauty Pro Filt'r Instant Retouch Primer dupes View full product details

bareMinerals Primer Good Hydrations Silky Face Primer Hydrate

bareMinerals

Primer Good Hydrations Silky Face Primer Hydrate

21%

Low match

Low irritancy

3/7

key actives shared

27%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Isododecane Polymethylsilsesquioxane Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasSqualane Copernicia cerifera wax Isopropyl myristate
Unlike the original, it hasCoconut alkanes Cyclopentasiloxane Dimethicone crosspolymer

See bareMinerals Primer Good Hydrations Silky Face Primer Hydrate dupes View full product details

Lottie London Coconut Primer

Lottie London

Coconut Primer

21%

Low match

Medium irritancy

2/7

key actives shared

24%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Isododecane Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasPolymethylsilsesquioxane Squalane Copernicia cerifera wax
Unlike the original, it hasPanthenol Cyclopentasiloxane Peg-10 dimethicone

See Lottie London Coconut Primer dupes View full product details

jane iredale Smooth Affair Illuminating Glow Face Primer

jane iredale

Smooth Affair Illuminating Glow Face Primer

20%

Low match

Low irritancy

3/7

key actives shared

15%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Polymethylsilsesquioxane Squalane Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasIsododecane Copernicia cerifera wax Isopropyl myristate
Unlike the original, it hasButyrospermum parkii butter Cocos nucifera oil Caprylic/capric triglyceride

See jane iredale Smooth Affair Illuminating Glow Face Primer dupes View full product details

REVOLUTION SKINCARE Correcting Primer Anti Redness Green

REVOLUTION SKINCARE

Correcting Primer Anti Redness Green

20%

Low match

Medium irritancy

4/7

key actives shared

36%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Isododecane Isopropyl myristate Ethylhexyl palmitate Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasPolymethylsilsesquioxane Squalane Copernicia cerifera wax
Unlike the original, it hasCyclopentasiloxane Dimethicone crosspolymer Methicone

See REVOLUTION SKINCARE Correcting Primer Anti Redness Green dupes View full product details

Lord & Berry Skin Control Mattifyer and Blurring Primer

Lord & Berry

Skin Control Mattifyer and Blurring Primer

19%

Low match

Low irritancy

2/7

key actives shared

24%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Polymethylsilsesquioxane Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasIsododecane Squalane Copernicia cerifera wax

See Lord & Berry Skin Control Mattifyer and Blurring Primer dupes View full product details

VDL Lumilayer Primer Fresh

VDL

Lumilayer Primer Fresh

19%

Low match

Medium irritancy

2/7

key actives shared

24%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Squalane Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasIsododecane Polymethylsilsesquioxane Copernicia cerifera wax
Unlike the original, it hasNiacinamide Adenosine Cyclopentasiloxane
It also works for:Anti-agingEvens skin toneAnti-blemish

See VDL Lumilayer Primer Fresh dupes View full product details

L'Oréal Paris Infallible Primer Shots - 03 Anti-Fatigue

L'Oréal Paris

Infallible Primer Shots - 03 Anti-Fatigue

19%

Low match

Medium irritancy

2/7

key actives shared

30%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Isododecane Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasPolymethylsilsesquioxane Squalane Copernicia cerifera wax
Unlike the original, it hasPeg-10 dimethicone Glycerin

See L'Oréal Paris Infallible Primer Shots - 03 Anti-Fatigue dupes View full product details

Lumene Natural Glow Moisturizing & Illuminating Primer

Lumene

Natural Glow Moisturizing & Illuminating Primer

19%

Low match

Medium irritancy

2/7

key actives shared

27%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Isododecane Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasPolymethylsilsesquioxane Squalane Copernicia cerifera wax
Unlike the original, it hasCetearyl dimethicone crosspolymer Betaine Sodium hyaluronate

See Lumene Natural Glow Moisturizing & Illuminating Primer dupes View full product details

It Cosmetics No. 50 Serum Collagen Veil Anti-Aging Face Primer

It Cosmetics

No. 50 Serum Collagen Veil Anti-Aging Face Primer

18%

Low match

High irritancy

4/7

key actives shared

24%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are primers.
Both contain:Isododecane Polymethylsilsesquioxane Squalane Dimethicone
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasCopernicia cerifera wax Isopropyl myristate Ethylhexyl palmitate
Unlike the original, it hasPalmitoyl oligopeptide Palmitoyl tetrapeptide-7 Adenosine
It also works for:Anti-agingAnti-oxidationEvens skin tone

See It Cosmetics No. 50 Serum Collagen Veil Anti-Aging Face Primer dupes View full product details

Affiliate links · As an Amazon Associate, WIMJ earns from qualifying purchases.

About Match %

70%+ - High match

40-69% - Medium match

<40% - Low match

Note: Ingredient concentrations are estimated; products aren't lab-tested. A close match doesn't guarantee the same feel.