What's In My Jar

Dupes & alternatives for Beekman 1802-Buttermilk Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm

Buttermilk Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm
Beekman 1802

Buttermilk Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm

Low irritancy Score: 100/100
View Product Search Another
20 alternatives found · Best match: 23% (Low)
No close formula dupes found
These are the closest alternatives based on WIMJ's similarity score. Consider filtering by irritancy or ingredients you want to avoid.
Barrier+ Foaming Oil Cleanser
Skinfix
Barrier+ Foaming Oil Cleanser
23%
Low match
$30.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINCAPRYLYL/CAPRYL GLUCOSIDE

Key differences

GLUCONOLACTONEPANTHENOLCHONDRUS CRISPUS EXTRACT +14 more
View details
Common ingredients (2)
GLYCERINCAPRYLYL/CAPRYL GLUCOSIDE
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula23%
Active ingredients19%
All ingredients21%
View full product details
Stelatopia Cleansing Oil
Mustela USA
Stelatopia Cleansing Oil
23%
Low match
$25.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINCAPRYLYL/CAPRYL GLUCOSIDE

Key differences

HELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED OIL UNSAPONIFIABLESPERSEA GRATISSIMA FRUIT EXTRACTHYDROXYPROPYL GUAR
View details
Common ingredients (2)
GLYCERINCAPRYLYL/CAPRYL GLUCOSIDE
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula23%
Active ingredients19%
All ingredients21%
View full product details
Cream Cleanser
iS Clinical
Cream Cleanser
22%
Low match
$38.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINSQUALANE

Key differences

AHNFELTIA CONCINNA EXTRACTCARTHAMUS TINCTORIUS SEED OILCHONDRUS CRISPUS +9 more
View details
Common ingredients (2)
GLYCERINSQUALANE
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula22%
Active ingredients38%
All ingredients11%
View full product details
Superior Omega Nutritive Gel Wash
HoliFrog
Superior Omega Nutritive Gel Wash
22%
Low match
$32.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINCAPRYLYL/CAPRYL GLUCOSIDE

Key differences

CAMELLIA OLEIFERA SEED OILLACTOBACILLUSLACTOBACILLUS FERMENT +9 more
View details
Common ingredients (2)
GLYCERINCAPRYLYL/CAPRYL GLUCOSIDE
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula22%
Active ingredients19%
All ingredients29%
View full product details
Cleansing Serum
Shani Darden Skin Care
Cleansing Serum
22%
Low match
$38.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINCAPRYLYL/CAPRYL GLUCOSIDE

Key differences

AVENA SATIVA KERNEL EXTRACTSODIUM HYALURONATEHEXYLENE GLYCOL +5 more
View details
Common ingredients (2)
GLYCERINCAPRYLYL/CAPRYL GLUCOSIDE
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula22%
Active ingredients19%
All ingredients14%
View full product details
Gentle Makeup Remover Wipes
MAKEUP BY MARIO
Gentle Makeup Remover Wipes
21%
Low match
$15.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINCAPRYLYL/CAPRYL GLUCOSIDE

Key differences

ALTHAEA OFFICINALIS ROOT EXTRACTCAPRYLIC/CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDESODIUM LAUROYL SARCOSINATE
View details
Common ingredients (2)
GLYCERINCAPRYLYL/CAPRYL GLUCOSIDE
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula21%
Active ingredients19%
All ingredients25%
View full product details
ALOE MICELLAR FACIAL CLEANSING GEL
Equilibra
ALOE MICELLAR FACIAL CLEANSING GEL
14%
Low match
Medium irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINCAPRYLYL/CAPRYL GLUCOSIDE

Key differences

SODIUM HYALURONATEPOLYGLYCERYL-6 OLEATESODIUM COCOYL GLUTAMATE +3 more
View details
Common ingredients (2)
GLYCERINCAPRYLYL/CAPRYL GLUCOSIDE
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula14%
Active ingredients19%
All ingredients29%
View full product details
Hydrating Micellar Cleansing Gel
Kind Natured
Hydrating Micellar Cleansing Gel
14%
Low match
$8.99
High irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINCAPRYLYL/CAPRYL GLUCOSIDE

Key differences

SALICYLIC ACIDCOCOS NUCIFERA FRUIT EXTRACTSACCHARIDE ISOMERATE +4 more
View details
Common ingredients (2)
GLYCERINCAPRYLYL/CAPRYL GLUCOSIDE
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula14%
Active ingredients19%
All ingredients29%
View full product details
Essential Cleansing Gel
ESPA
Essential Cleansing Gel
13%
Low match
$46.50
High irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINCAPRYLYL/CAPRYL GLUCOSIDE

Key differences

COCAMIDOPROPYL BETAINEPEG-120 METHYL GLUCOSE DIOLEATEPOLYSORBATE 20 +4 more
View details
Common ingredients (2)
GLYCERINCAPRYLYL/CAPRYL GLUCOSIDE
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula13%
Active ingredients19%
All ingredients21%
View full product details

About Similarity Scores

Our similarity score compares product formulas based on shared active ingredients, hero ingredients, and overall formula composition. A higher score means a more similar formula.

70%+ - High match
40-69% - Medium match
<40% - Low match

Note: Similarity is based on WIMJ's formula analysis (actives + overall formula similarity). Ingredient concentrations are estimated; products aren't lab-tested. A similar formula doesn't guarantee the same texture or feel.