What's In My Jar

Dupes & alternatives for Thayers-Witch Hazel Blemish Clearing Cleanser

Witch Hazel Blemish Clearing Cleanser
Thayers

Witch Hazel Blemish Clearing Cleanser

Medium irritancy Score: 100/100
View Product Search Another
20 alternatives found · Best match: 38% (Low)
No close formula dupes found
These are the closest alternatives based on WIMJ's similarity score. Consider filtering by irritancy or ingredients you want to avoid.
Earth Sourced Perfectly Natural Cleansing Gel Full size
Paula's choice
Earth Sourced Perfectly Natural Cleansing Gel Full size
38%
Low match
$22.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINDECYL GLUCOSIDELAURYL GLUCOSIDE +1 more

Key differences

GLYCERYL OLEATESODIUM COCOAMPHOACETATESODIUM COCOYL GLUTAMATE +2 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula38%
Active ingredients64%
All ingredients56%
View full product details
Benzoyl Peroxide Cream Cleanser 5%
Naturium
Benzoyl Peroxide Cream Cleanser 5%
35%
Low match
$18.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINSODIUM COCOYL ISETHIONATEXANTHAN GUM

Key differences

ACETYL GLUCOSAMINECOCAMIDOPROPYL BETAINECOCAMIDOPROPYL HYDROXYSULTAINE +3 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula35%
Active ingredients43%
All ingredients44%
View full product details
Barrier+ Foaming Oil Cleanser
Skinfix
Barrier+ Foaming Oil Cleanser
34%
Low match
$30.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

BETAINEGLYCERINSODIUM COCOYL ISETHIONATE +1 more

Key differences

GLUCONOLACTONEPANTHENOLCHONDRUS CRISPUS EXTRACT +12 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula34%
Active ingredients43%
All ingredients56%
View full product details
Water Drench Cloud Cream Cleanser
Peter Thomas Roth
Water Drench Cloud Cream Cleanser
34%
Low match
$10.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINSODIUM COCOYL ISETHIONATEXANTHAN GUM

Key differences

SODIUM HYALURONATECOCOS NUCIFERA OILSODIUM PCA +9 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula34%
Active ingredients43%
All ingredients38%
View full product details
Avocado Fragrance-Free Daily Cream Cleanser
Yes to
Avocado Fragrance-Free Daily Cream Cleanser
33%
Low match
$6.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINXANTHAN GUMDECYL GLUCOSIDE

Key differences

PERSEA GRATISSIMA OILSODIUM HYALURONATECAPRYLIC/CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDE +3 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula33%
Active ingredients43%
All ingredients44%
View full product details
RE-MOVE Purifying Cleansing Gel
My Clarins
RE-MOVE Purifying Cleansing Gel
32%
Low match
$30.00
Medium irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINLAURYL GLUCOSIDEXANTHAN GUM +1 more

Key differences

TITANIUM DIOXIDEHEXYLENE GLYCOLSODIUM COCOYL AMINO ACIDS +2 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula32%
Active ingredients64%
All ingredients44%
View full product details
Re-Move Purifying Cleansing Gel
Clarins
Re-Move Purifying Cleansing Gel
32%
Low match
$24.00
Medium irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINLAURYL GLUCOSIDEXANTHAN GUM +1 more

Key differences

TITANIUM DIOXIDEHEXYLENE GLYCOLSODIUM COCOYL AMINO ACIDS +2 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula32%
Active ingredients64%
All ingredients44%
View full product details
Superior Omega Gel Wash
HoliFrog
Superior Omega Gel Wash
32%
Low match
$29.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINXANTHAN GUMDECYL GLUCOSIDE

Key differences

CAMELLIA OLEIFERA SEED OILLACTOBACILLUSLACTOBACILLUS FERMENT +8 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula32%
Active ingredients43%
All ingredients38%
View full product details
Cleanser
Dr. Barbara Sturm
Cleanser
32%
Low match
$50.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINLAURYL GLUCOSIDE

Key differences

SALICYLIC ACIDUREAPANTHENOL +5 more
View details
Common ingredients (2)
GLYCERINLAURYL GLUCOSIDE
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula32%
Active ingredients21%
All ingredients38%
View full product details
Milk Melt Vegan Oat Cleanser
BYBI
Milk Melt Vegan Oat Cleanser
31%
Low match
$14.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINXANTHAN GUMLAURYL GLUCOSIDE

Key differences

LACTIC ACIDLACTOBACILLUS FERMENTCAPRYLIC/CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDE +9 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula31%
Active ingredients43%
All ingredients31%
View full product details
pH BALANCED PATCHOULI + CHERIMOYA GEL CLEANSER
instant clarity. no fuss. no drama.
pH BALANCED PATCHOULI + CHERIMOYA GEL CLEANSER
31%
Low match
Low irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINSODIUM COCOYL ISETHIONATE

Key differences

PANTHENOLSODIUM LAUROYL METHYL ISETHIONATESODIUM LAURYLGLUCOSIDES HYDROXYPROPYLSULFONATE +3 more
View details
Common ingredients (2)
GLYCERINSODIUM COCOYL ISETHIONATE
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula31%
Active ingredients21%
All ingredients44%
View full product details
Ultra Calm Cleansing Cream
ALASTIN Skincare
Ultra Calm Cleansing Cream
31%
Low match
$45.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINBETAINEXANTHAN GUM

Key differences

PANTHENOLLINOLEIC ACIDDIMETHICONE +13 more
View details
Common ingredients (3)
GLYCERINBETAINEXANTHAN GUM
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula31%
Active ingredients21%
All ingredients44%
View full product details
Daily Foaming Gel Cleanser
L'Oréal Paris
Daily Foaming Gel Cleanser
31%
Low match
$4.99
Low irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINSODIUM COCOYL ISETHIONATE

Key differences

SALICYLIC ACIDCOCONUT ACIDGLYCERYL OLEATE +10 more
View details
Common ingredients (2)
GLYCERINSODIUM COCOYL ISETHIONATE
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula31%
Active ingredients21%
All ingredients31%
View full product details

About Similarity Scores

Our similarity score compares product formulas based on shared active ingredients, hero ingredients, and overall formula composition. A higher score means a more similar formula.

70%+ - High match
40-69% - Medium match
<40% - Low match

Note: Similarity is based on WIMJ's formula analysis (actives + overall formula similarity). Ingredient concentrations are estimated; products aren't lab-tested. A similar formula doesn't guarantee the same texture or feel.