Dupes & alternatives for Parnell - Panthenol 3.28 Heartleaf Calming Toner

	Parnell - Panthenol 3.28 Heartleaf Calming Toner	DERMATORY - Retinal Essence Toner Sponsored	DERMATORY - Retinal Essence Toner	Miraculum - Bakuchiol toner	Derma E - Anti-Wrinkle Toner	celimax - Dual Barrier Creamy Toner	BYOMA - HYDRATING MILKY TONER	ROUND LAB - Soybean Nourishing Toner	Summer Fridays - Jet Lag Skin Soothing Hydration Mist	Benton - Fermentation Essence	mixsoon - Master Soft Toner Mini	LABIOTTE - Collagen Full Up Treatment Essence
Price
WIMJ similarity score		64%	64%	55%	55%	42%	42%	41%	39%	39%	38%	37%
Key ingredients	bakuchiol ceramide np +7 more	Common: bakuchiol ceramide np +2 more Other: niacinamide retinal +6 more	Common: bakuchiol ceramide np +2 more Other: niacinamide retinal +6 more	Common: bakuchiol panthenol Other: centella asiatica extract glycerin +10 more	Common: bakuchiol panthenol Other: retinol glycolic acid +2 more	Common: panthenol ceramide np +2 more Other: ceramide as ceramide eop +9 more	Common: panthenol ceramide np Other: glycerin limnanthes alba seed oil +7 more	Common: ceramide np panthenol Other: adenosine glycerin +4 more	Common: panthenol ceramide np Other: centella asiatica extract ectoin +4 more	Common: ceramide np panthenol +1 more Other: copper tripeptide-1 tripeptide-1 +11 more	Common: panthenol ceramide np +1 more Other: madecassoside sodium hyaluronate +2 more	Common: panthenol ceramide np +3 more Other: niacinamide adenosine +16 more
Irritancy	IRRITANCY LOW	IRRITANCY MEDIUM	IRRITANCY MEDIUM	IRRITANCY HIGH	IRRITANCY HIGH	IRRITANCY LOW	IRRITANCY LOW	IRRITANCY LOW	IRRITANCY LOW	IRRITANCY LOW	IRRITANCY LOW	IRRITANCY MEDIUM
Potential Irritants	ascorbic acid Has skin benefit? bakuchiol Has skin benefit? +9 more	retinal Has skin benefit? ulmus davidiana root extract Has skin benefit? +13 more	retinal Has skin benefit? ulmus davidiana root extract Has skin benefit? +13 more	parfum Has skin benefit? citrus limon peel extract Has skin benefit? +11 more	parfum Has skin benefit? chamomilla recutita flower extract Has skin benefit? +10 more	disodium edta Has skin benefit? ethylhexylglycerin Has skin benefit? +6 more	pullulan Has skin benefit? cetearyl glucoside Has skin benefit? +9 more	disodium edta Has skin benefit? caprylic/capric triglyceride Has skin benefit? +5 more	potassium sorbate Has skin benefit? citric acid Has skin benefit? +10 more	caprylyl glycol Has skin benefit? polyglyceryl-10 laurate Has skin benefit? +4 more	sodium polyacryloyldimethyl taurate Has skin benefit? caprylic/capric triglyceride Has skin benefit? +4 more	parfum Has skin benefit? arctium lappa root extract Has skin benefit? +25 more
All ingredients	water Has skin benefit? panthenol Has skin benefit? +25 more	water Has skin benefit? propanediol Has skin benefit? +31 more	water Has skin benefit? propanediol Has skin benefit? +31 more	water Has skin benefit? propanediol Has skin benefit? +27 more	water Has skin benefit? glycerin Has skin benefit? +17 more	water Has skin benefit? dipropylene glycol Has skin benefit? +32 more	water Has skin benefit? butylene glycol Has skin benefit? +27 more	water Has skin benefit? propanediol Has skin benefit? +24 more	water Has skin benefit? glycerin Has skin benefit? +29 more	galactomyces ferment filtrate Has skin benefit? lactobacillus/collagen ferment filtrate Has skin benefit? +30 more	water Has skin benefit? butylene glycol Has skin benefit? +16 more	water Has skin benefit? methylpropanediol Has skin benefit? +72 more