How well do the ingredients match what the product promises?
Filter by how likely the formula is to cause irritation.
Exclude common irritants and allergens from your results.
After a lot of research this is the best dupe I found (for my purposes) of my beloved Ample:N Ceramide Shot Ampoule. The culprit is Butylene Glycol which can be drying and cause redness if it accumulates on my skin. It is in A LOT of products. In Ample:N Ceramide Shot Ampoule it is the 2nd ingredient of 35, possibly 6-8%. In Round Lab Soy Bean Nourishing Serum it is 40th of 52, possibly 0.2-0.35%.
This has 5 ceramides, glycerin, squalane, panthenol, cholesterol all of which are good ingredients for my sensitive, mature skin. The niacinamide is lower in the ingredients so may not be very effective. This serum is not as soothing (creamy) as the Ample:N but it has worked well this summer for me. I have used it every other night for 12 weeks. The real test will be this winter and I will update my review then.
Using products with little or no Butylene Glycol and Sodium Hyaluronate has done more to help my rosacea, redness and dryness than anything else.