60%
Medium match
Medium irritancy
4/4
key actives shared
2/2
heroes shared
100%
of the original's ingredients
Same formula
Why it's a dupe
- Both are moisturizers.
- Same hero ingredients:LanolinMineral oil
- Both contain:OctinoxateDimethicone
Mentholatum Natural ice Original Flavor SPF 15 Medicated Lip Protectant/Sunscreen Dupes
There is no exact dupe for Mentholatum Natural ice Original Flavor SPF 15 Medicated Lip Protectant/Sunscreen. The nearest formula is Natural Ice Medicated Lip Protectant/Sunscreen SPF 15 Original (60% match), which shares all 5 key ingredients (including Mineral oil, Lanolin and Petrolatum).
Match % combines shared ingredients, the first five ingredients, shared actives and hero ingredients, irritancy (lower counts in the alternative's favour), texture and body area. Only products in the same routine step are compared.
Mentholatum
Natural ice Original Flavor SPF 15 Medicated Lip Protectant/Sunscreen
SPF 15Medium irritancy Score: 75/100
- What it is
- Moisturizer with 5 key ingredients
- Hero ingredients
- LanolinMineral oil
20 alternatives found · Best match: 60% (Medium)
Top dupes for Mentholatum Natural ice Original Flavor SPF 15 Medicated Lip Protectant/Sunscreen
ChapStick
Moisturizer, Cool Mint Flavor, Lip Balm Tube, Skin Protectant, Lip Care, SPF 15, - 12 Sticks
57%
Medium match
Medium irritancy
3/4
key actives shared
2/2
heroes shared
56%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are moisturizers.
- Same hero ingredients:LanolinMineral oil
- Both contain:Octinoxate
- The original also hasDimethicone
- Unlike the original, it hasAvobenzoneCopernicia cerifera waxIsocetyl stearate
Coppertone
Lip Balm SPF 50
53%
Medium match
Medium irritancy
2/4
key actives shared
2/2
heroes shared
67%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are sunscreens.
- Same hero ingredients:LanolinMineral oil
- Both work for:Moisturizing
- The original also hasOctinoxateDimethicone
- Unlike the original, it hasAvobenzoneHomosalateOxybenzone
- It also works for:Anti-agingAnti-oxidation
49%
Medium match
Low irritancy
2/4
key actives shared
1/2
heroes shared
44%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are moisturizers.
- Same hero ingredients:Lanolin
- Both contain:Octinoxate
- The original also hasMineral oilDimethicone
- Unlike the original, it hasAvobenzonePersea gratissima oilBeeswax
- It also works for:Anti-oxidation
Carmex
Pineapple & Mint Tube
48%
Medium match
High irritancy
3/4
key actives shared
2/2
heroes shared
67%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are moisturizers.
- Same hero ingredients:LanolinMineral oil
- Both contain:Octinoxate
- The original also hasDimethicone
- Unlike the original, it hasCetyl estersTheobroma cacao seed butterCera alba
48%
Medium match
Medium irritancy
2/4
key actives shared
1/2
heroes shared
67%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are moisturizers.
- Same hero ingredients:Mineral oil
- Both contain:Dimethicone
- The original also hasLanolinOctinoxate
- Unlike the original, it hasOxybenzoneSunflower seed oilTitanium dioxide
- It also works for:Anti-oxidationAnti-aging
48%
Medium match
Low irritancy
2/4
key actives shared
1/2
heroes shared
33%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are moisturizers.
- Same hero ingredients:Lanolin
- Both contain:Octinoxate
- The original also hasMineral oilDimethicone
- Unlike the original, it hasJojoba oil
46%
Medium match
High irritancy
4/4
key actives shared
2/2
heroes shared
100%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are moisturizers.
- Same hero ingredients:LanolinMineral oil
- Both contain:OctinoxateDimethicone
- Unlike the original, it hasBeeswaxCetyl palmitateIsopropyl myristate
Australian Gold
SPF 30 Lipbalm Stick
45%
Medium match
High irritancy
3/4
key actives shared
2/2
heroes shared
56%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are sunscreens.
- Same hero ingredients:LanolinMineral oil
- Both contain:Octinoxate
- Both work for:Moisturizing
- The original also hasDimethicone
- Unlike the original, it hasSynthetic beeswaxOxybenzoneCocos nucifera oil
Rohto Mentholatum
Premium Melty Cream Lip Balm SPF 26 PA+++ - 2 Types
43%
Medium match
Medium irritancy
2/4
key actives shared
1/2
heroes shared
33%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are moisturizers.
- Same hero ingredients:Mineral oil
- Both contain:Octinoxate
- The original also hasLanolinDimethicone
- Unlike the original, it hasCeramide 3Ceramide 2Butyrospermum parkii butter
42%
Medium match
Low irritancy
3/4
key actives shared
1/2
heroes shared
44%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are moisturizers.
- Same hero ingredients:Mineral oil
- Both contain:OctinoxateDimethicone
- The original also hasLanolin
- Unlike the original, it hasAvobenzoneTinosorb sTitanium dioxide
- It also works for:Anti-agingSun protection
41%
Medium match
High irritancy
4/4
key actives shared
2/2
heroes shared
89%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are sunscreens.
- Same hero ingredients:LanolinMineral oil
- Both contain:OctinoxateDimethicone
- Both work for:Moisturizing
- Unlike the original, it hasRicinus communis seed oilOxybenzoneCopernicia cerifera wax
Sesderma
REPASKIN Lips SPF50
40%
Medium match
Medium irritancy
1/4
key actives shared
1/2
heroes shared
33%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are moisturizers.
- Same hero ingredients:Lanolin
- The original also hasMineral oilOctinoxateDimethicone
- Unlike the original, it hasOctocryleneHomosalateTinosorb s
- It also works for:Sun protectionAnti-aging
Skin In Motion Ltd
Plump IT SPF30 Tinted Lip Balm Sheer Berry
40%
Medium match
Medium irritancy
1/4
key actives shared
1/2
heroes shared
33%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are moisturizers.
- Same hero ingredients:Lanolin
- The original also hasOctinoxateDimethicone
- Unlike the original, it hasTripeptide-1Caprylic/capric triglycerideTitanium dioxide
- It also works for:Anti-aging
O'Keeffe's
OKeeffes Lip Repair Stick, SPF 35
39%
Low match
Medium irritancy
2/4
key actives shared
0/2
heroes shared
44%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are moisturizers.
- Both contain:OctinoxateDimethicone
- The original also hasLanolinMineral oil
- Unlike the original, it hasAvobenzoneOctocryleneCera alba
- It also works for:Sun protectionAnti-aging
39%
Low match
Medium irritancy
3/4
key actives shared
1/2
heroes shared
44%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are moisturizers.
- Same hero ingredients:Mineral oil
- Both contain:OctinoxateDimethicone
- The original also hasLanolin
- Unlike the original, it hasOxybenzoneCera microcristallinaCopernicia cerifera wax
Softlips
Pearl Tinted Lip Balm SPF 15
38%
Low match
Medium irritancy
2/4
key actives shared
1/2
heroes shared
67%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are moisturizers.
- Same hero ingredients:Mineral oil
- Both contain:Octinoxate
- The original also hasLanolinDimethicone
- Unlike the original, it hasLanolin oilMeadowfoam seed oilBis-diglyceryl polyacyladipate-2
High irritancy
3/4
key actives shared
2/2
heroes shared
56%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are moisturizers.
- Same hero ingredients:LanolinMineral oil
- Both contain:Dimethicone
- The original also hasOctinoxate
- Unlike the original, it hasHydroquinoneOxybenzoneZinc oxide
- It also works for:Sun protectionEvens skin toneAnti-aging
37%
Low match
Medium irritancy
1/4
key actives shared
0/2
heroes shared
56%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are moisturizers.
- Both contain:Octinoxate
- The original also hasLanolinMineral oilDimethicone
- Unlike the original, it hasAvobenzoneCera albaCopernicia cerifera wax
- It also works for:Anti-agingSun protection
Well People
Daygleamer Mineral Sunscreen Serum SPF 34
36%
Low match
Medium irritancy
2/4
key actives shared
1/2
heroes shared
44%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both are sunscreens.
- Same hero ingredients:Mineral oil
- Both contain:Dimethicone
- Both work for:Moisturizing
- The original also hasLanolinOctinoxate
- Unlike the original, it hasAvobenzoneOxybenzone
- It also works for:Anti-agingEvens skin tone
Affiliate links · As an Amazon Associate, WIMJ earns from qualifying purchases.
About Match %
70%+ - High match
40-69% - Medium match
<40% - Low match
Note: Ingredient concentrations are estimated; products aren't lab-tested. A close match doesn't guarantee the same feel.