60%
Medium match
$1.29
Medium irritancy Why it matches
PARAFFINUM LIQUIDUMLANOLINPETROLATUM +2 more
View details
Common ingredients (5)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula60%
Hero ingredients100%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients100%
Dupes & alternatives for Mentholatum-Natural ice Original Flavor SPF 15 Medicated Lip Protectant/Sunscreen
Mentholatum
Natural ice Original Flavor SPF 15 Medicated Lip Protectant/Sunscreen
SPF 15Medium irritancy Score: 75/100
20 alternatives found · Best match: 60% (Medium)
55%
Medium match
$1.50
Medium irritancy Why it matches
PARAFFINUM LIQUIDUMLANOLINPETROLATUM +1 more
Key differences
ISOCETYL STEARATEBUTYL METHOXYDIBENZOYLMETHANECOPERNICIA CERIFERA WAX
View details
Common ingredients (4)
Different ingredients (3)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula55%
Hero ingredients100%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients56%
Coppertone
Lip Balm SPF 5052%
Medium match
Medium irritancy
Why it matches
PARAFFINUM LIQUIDUMPETROLATUMLANOLIN
Key differences
COPERNICIA CERIFERA WAXHOMOSALATEISOCETYL STEARATE +6 more
View details
Common ingredients (3)
Different ingredients (9)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula52%
Hero ingredients100%
Active ingredients90%
All ingredients56%
49%
Medium match
$8.00
Low irritancy Why it matches
PETROLATUMLANOLINETHYLHEXYL METHOXYCINNAMATE
Key differences
BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERCAMELLIA SINENSIS LEAF EXTRACTCYCLOPENTASILOXANE +4 more
View details
Common ingredients (3)
Different ingredients (7)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula49%
Hero ingredients100%
Active ingredients90%
All ingredients44%
Carmex
Pineapple & Mint Tube48%
Medium match
$2.06
High irritancy Why it matches
PARAFFINUM LIQUIDUMPETROLATUMLANOLIN +1 more
Key differences
CERA ALBABEESWAXTHEOBROMA CACAO SEED BUTTER +1 more
View details
Common ingredients (4)
Different ingredients (4)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula48%
Hero ingredients100%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients67%
48%
Medium match
$7.99
Medium irritancy Why it matches
PARAFFINUM LIQUIDUMPETROLATUMDIMETHICONE
Key differences
PANTHENOLHELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED OILLYSINE +4 more
View details
Common ingredients (3)
Different ingredients (7)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula48%
Hero ingredients100%
Active ingredients90%
All ingredients67%
48%
Medium match
$7.40
Low irritancy Why it matches
LANOLINPETROLATUMETHYLHEXYL METHOXYCINNAMATE
Key differences
SIMMONDSIA CHINENSIS SEED OILZINC OXIDE
View details
Common ingredients (3)
Different ingredients (2)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula48%
Hero ingredients100%
Active ingredients90%
All ingredients33%
46%
Medium match
$4.24
High irritancy Why it matches
PARAFFINUM LIQUIDUMPETROLATUMLANOLIN +2 more
Key differences
ISOPROPYL MYRISTATELANOLIN OILBEESWAX +1 more
View details
Common ingredients (5)
Different ingredients (4)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula46%
Hero ingredients100%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients100%
Australian Gold
SPF 30 Lipbalm Stick45%
Medium match
$4.95
High irritancy Why it matches
PARAFFINUM LIQUIDUMPETROLATUMLANOLIN +1 more
Key differences
HELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED OILPHENYL TRIMETHICONESYNTHETIC BEESWAX +6 more
View details
Common ingredients (4)
Different ingredients (9)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula45%
Hero ingredients100%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients56%
Rohto Mentholatum
Premium Melty Cream Lip Balm SPF 26 PA+++ - 2 Types43%
Medium match
$7.02
Medium irritancy Why it matches
PARAFFINUM LIQUIDUMPETROLATUMETHYLHEXYL METHOXYCINNAMATE
Key differences
CERAMIDE 2CERAMIDE 3PERSEA GRATISSIMA OIL +5 more
View details
Common ingredients (3)
Different ingredients (8)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula43%
Hero ingredients100%
Active ingredients90%
All ingredients33%
42%
Medium match
$6.99
Low irritancy Why it matches
PARAFFINUM LIQUIDUMPETROLATUMDIMETHICONE +1 more
Key differences
RICINUS COMMUNIS SEED OILBIS-ETHYLHEXYLOXYPHENOL METHOXYPHENYL TRIAZINETITANIUM DIOXIDE +1 more
View details
Common ingredients (4)
Different ingredients (4)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula42%
Hero ingredients67%
Active ingredients90%
All ingredients44%
Skin In Motion Ltd
Plump IT SPF30 Tinted Lip Balm Sheer Berry40%
Medium match
$17.00
Medium irritancy Why it matches
PARAFFINUM LIQUIDUMPETROLATUMLANOLIN
Key differences
TRIPEPTIDE-1HELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED WAXJOJOBA ESTERS +9 more
View details
Common ingredients (3)
Different ingredients (12)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula40%
Hero ingredients100%
Active ingredients60%
All ingredients33%
Sesderma
REPASKIN Lips SPF5040%
Medium match
Medium irritancy
Why it matches
PETROLATUMLANOLIN
Key differences
BUTYL METHOXYDIBENZOYLMETHANEBUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTER EXTRACTCAPRYLIC/CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDE +9 more
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Different ingredients (12)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula40%
Hero ingredients100%
Active ingredients60%
All ingredients33%
O'Keeffe's
OKeeffes Lip Repair Stick, SPF 3539%
Low match
$4.79
Medium irritancy Why it matches
PETROLATUMDIMETHICONEETHYLHEXYL METHOXYCINNAMATE
Key differences
BUTYL METHOXYDIBENZOYLMETHANEBUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTEROCTOCRYLENE +4 more
View details
Common ingredients (3)
Different ingredients (7)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula39%
Hero ingredients67%
Active ingredients90%
All ingredients44%
39%
Low match
Medium irritancy
Why it matches
PARAFFINUM LIQUIDUMDIMETHICONEETHYLHEXYL METHOXYCINNAMATE
Key differences
CERA MICROCRISTALLINACOPERNICIA CERIFERA WAXTHEOBROMA CACAO SEED BUTTER +2 more
View details
Common ingredients (3)
Different ingredients (5)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula39%
Hero ingredients67%
Active ingredients90%
All ingredients44%
Softlips
Pearl Tinted Lip Balm SPF 1538%
Low match
$8.49
Medium irritancy Why it matches
PARAFFINUM LIQUIDUMETHYLHEXYL METHOXYCINNAMATE
Key differences
COPERNICIA CERIFERA WAXBIS-DIGLYCERYL POLYACYLADIPATE-2LIMNANTHES ALBA SEED OIL +2 more
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Different ingredients (5)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula38%
Hero ingredients67%
Active ingredients60%
All ingredients67%
37%
Low match
$12.00
Medium irritancy Why it matches
PETROLATUMETHYLHEXYL METHOXYCINNAMATE
Key differences
BUTYL METHOXYDIBENZOYLMETHANEBUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERCOCOS NUCIFERA FRUIT EXTRACT +7 more
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Different ingredients (10)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula37%
Hero ingredients67%
Active ingredients60%
All ingredients56%
Piz Buin
Glacier Cream - High SPF3035%
Low match
$10.99
Medium irritancy Why it matches
PARAFFINUM LIQUIDUMPETROLATUMDIMETHICONE
Key differences
CERA MICROCRISTALLINADIETHYLAMINO HYDROXYBENZOYL HEXYL BENZOATEOCTOCRYLENE +3 more
View details
Common ingredients (3)
Different ingredients (6)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula35%
Hero ingredients100%
Active ingredients90%
All ingredients56%
35%
Low match
$5.49
Medium irritancy Why it matches
PETROLATUMETHYLHEXYL METHOXYCINNAMATE
Key differences
PANTHENOLBUTYL METHOXYDIBENZOYLMETHANEBUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTER +6 more
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Different ingredients (9)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula35%
Hero ingredients67%
Active ingredients60%
All ingredients33%
34%
Low match
$14.98
High irritancy Why it matches
PARAFFINUM LIQUIDUMPETROLATUMETHYLHEXYL METHOXYCINNAMATE
Key differences
ISOPROPYL MYRISTATEOCTOCRYLENESIMMONDSIA CHINENSIS SEED OIL +2 more
View details
Common ingredients (3)
Different ingredients (5)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula34%
Hero ingredients100%
Active ingredients90%
All ingredients44%
About Similarity Scores
Our similarity score compares product formulas based on shared active ingredients, hero ingredients, and overall formula composition. A higher score means a more similar formula.
70%+ - High match
40-69% - Medium match
<40% - Low match
Note: Similarity is based on WIMJ's formula analysis (actives + overall formula similarity). Ingredient concentrations are estimated; products aren't lab-tested. A similar formula doesn't guarantee the same texture or feel.