What's In My Jar

Dupes & alternatives for Dr. PAWPAW-Shea Butter Multipurpose Soothing Balm

Shea Butter Multipurpose Soothing Balm
Dr. PAWPAW

Shea Butter Multipurpose Soothing Balm

Medium irritancy Score: 37/100
View Product Search Another
20 alternatives found · Best match: 26% (Low)
No close formula dupes found
These are the closest alternatives based on WIMJ's similarity score. Consider filtering by irritancy or ingredients you want to avoid.
Elixir Tinted Lip Oil Balm - Alba
RÓEN
Elixir Tinted Lip Oil Balm - Alba
26%
Low match
$32.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

ARGANIA SPINOSA KERNEL OILHELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED OILRICINUS COMMUNIS SEED OIL +1 more

Key differences

BIS-DIGLYCERYL POLYACYLADIPATE-2COPERNICIA CERIFERA WAXSODIUM HYALURONATE +2 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula26%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients38%
View full product details
Cocolips Balm - Sunstone
Salt by Hendrix
Cocolips Balm - Sunstone
25%
Low match
$17.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

ARGANIA SPINOSA KERNEL OILBUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERRICINUS COMMUNIS SEED OIL +1 more

Key differences

COCOS NUCIFERA OILCOPERNICIA CERIFERA WAXTHEOBROMA CACAO SEED BUTTER +2 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula25%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients31%
View full product details
Certified Organic Cream Illuminisor
INIKA
Certified Organic Cream Illuminisor
25%
Low match
$6.90
Low irritancy

Why it matches

ARGANIA SPINOSA KERNEL OILBUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERRICINUS COMMUNIS SEED OIL

Key differences

COCOS NUCIFERA OILCOPERNICIA CERIFERA WAXEUPHORBIA CERIFERA CERA +3 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula25%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients31%
View full product details
Nipple + Lip
HATCH MAMA
Nipple + Lip
24%
Low match
$28.00
Medium irritancy

Why it matches

ARGANIA SPINOSA KERNEL OILBUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERHELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED OIL +2 more

Key differences

LINOLEIC ACIDASTROCARYUM MURUMURU SEED BUTTERBEESWAX +5 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula24%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients46%
View full product details
100% Natural Moisturizing Matte Lip Crayon Carolina Coast, Carolina Coast
Burt's Bees
100% Natural Moisturizing Matte Lip Crayon Carolina Coast, Carolina Coast
24%
Low match
Medium irritancy

Why it matches

BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERHELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED OILRICINUS COMMUNIS SEED OIL +1 more

Key differences

ALEURITES MOLUCCANUS SEED OILBEESWAXCAPRYLIC/CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDE +5 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula24%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients46%
View full product details
Chubby Stick
Clinique
Chubby Stick
23%
Low match
$19.00
Medium irritancy

Why it matches

BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERHELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED OILRICINUS COMMUNIS SEED OIL +1 more

Key differences

BEESWAXCAPRYLIC/CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDECERA ALBA +4 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula23%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients38%
View full product details
Nudist Multi-Use Cream
W3LL PEOPLE
Nudist Multi-Use Cream
23%
Low match
$22.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERHELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED OILRICINUS COMMUNIS SEED OIL

Key differences

CAMELLIA SINENSIS LEAFCOPERNICIA CERIFERA WAXHELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED WAX +5 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula23%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients38%
View full product details
Lip Balm - Whipped Shea Butter
evanhealy
Lip Balm - Whipped Shea Butter
23%
Low match
$7.96
Low irritancy

Why it matches

ARGANIA SPINOSA KERNEL OILBUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERHELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED OIL +1 more

Key differences

BEESWAXCERA ALBACOCOS NUCIFERA OIL +3 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula23%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients38%
View full product details
Amorem Nourishing Lip Balm
Le Couvent des Minimes
Amorem Nourishing Lip Balm
23%
Low match
$14.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERHELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED OILRICINUS COMMUNIS SEED OIL

Key differences

COPERNICIA CERIFERA WAXHELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED WAXVITIS VINIFERA SEED OIL
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula23%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients31%
View full product details
More Than Lip Balm
Sioris
More Than Lip Balm
23%
Low match
$7.08
Low irritancy

Why it matches

BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERHELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED OILRICINUS COMMUNIS SEED OIL

Key differences

BEESWAXCOCOS NUCIFERA OILPERSEA GRATISSIMA OIL +1 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula23%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients31%
View full product details
Heavenly Body Oil
Antipodes
Heavenly Body Oil
23%
Low match
$39.20
Low irritancy

Why it matches

ARGANIA SPINOSA KERNEL OILBUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERRICINUS COMMUNIS SEED OIL +1 more

Key differences

BEESWAXCAPRYLIC/CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDECERA ALBA +7 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula23%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients31%
View full product details
Clean Lip Balm & Scrub
SEPHORA COLLECTION
Clean Lip Balm & Scrub
22%
Low match
$7.00
Medium irritancy

Why it matches

ARGANIA SPINOSA KERNEL OILBUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERHELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED OIL +2 more

Key differences

COPERNICIA CERIFERA WAXHELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED CERAHELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED WAX +2 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula22%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients46%
View full product details
100% Virgin Coconut Oil Overnight Face Oil
SheaMoisture
100% Virgin Coconut Oil Overnight Face Oil
22%
Low match
$10.49
Low irritancy

Why it matches

ARGANIA SPINOSA KERNEL OILBUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERRICINUS COMMUNIS SEED OIL

Key differences

CAPRYLIC/CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDECOCOS NUCIFERA FRUIT EXTRACTCOCOS NUCIFERA OIL +3 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula22%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients23%
View full product details
Green Power With Hemp Seed Oil Sugar Lip Scrub
Elizabeth Grant
Green Power With Hemp Seed Oil Sugar Lip Scrub
22%
Low match
Low irritancy

Why it matches

BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERHELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED OILRICINUS COMMUNIS SEED OIL

Key differences

PANTHENOLCANNABIS SATIVA SEED OILGLYCERIN +4 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula22%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients23%
View full product details
Topialyse Plant-Based Nourishing Lip Balm
SVR
Topialyse Plant-Based Nourishing Lip Balm
22%
Low match
$4.50
Low irritancy

Why it matches

BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERHELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED OILRICINUS COMMUNIS SEED OIL

Key differences

CAMELINA SATIVA SEED OILCAPRYLIC/CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDECOPERNICIA CERIFERA WAX +1 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula22%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients23%
View full product details

About Similarity Scores

Our similarity score compares product formulas based on shared active ingredients, hero ingredients, and overall formula composition. A higher score means a more similar formula.

70%+ - High match
40-69% - Medium match
<40% - Low match

Note: Similarity is based on WIMJ's formula analysis (actives + overall formula similarity). Ingredient concentrations are estimated; products aren't lab-tested. A similar formula doesn't guarantee the same texture or feel.