What's In My Jar

Supply Co. Healing Post Shave Spray Dupes

We found no close formula dupe for Supply Co. Healing Post Shave Spray. The nearest product, Zirh Soothe Gel Post Shave Solution, is only a 35% match: it shares 2 of the original's 4 key ingredients (Allantoin and Glycerin).

Match % combines shared ingredients, the first five ingredients, shared actives and hero ingredients, irritancy (lower counts in the alternative's favour), texture and body area. Only products in the same routine step are compared.

Supply Co. Healing Post Shave Spray

Healing Post Shave Spray

Medium irritancy Score: 75/100

What it is: Shaving product with 4 key ingredients
Works for: Moisturizing

View Product Search Another

15 alternatives found · Best match: 35% (Low)

View:

No close formula dupes found

These are the closest alternatives based on WIMJ's similarity score. Consider filtering by irritancy or ingredients you want to avoid.

Top dupes for Supply Co. Healing Post Shave Spray

Zirh Soothe Gel Post Shave Solution

Zirh

Soothe Gel Post Shave Solution

35%

Low match

Low irritancy

1/3

key actives shared

55%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are shaving products.
Both contain:Glycerin
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasButyrospermum parkii butter
Unlike the original, it hasLycium barbarum fruit extract Methyl gluceth-20 Sodium pca
It also works for:Anti-oxidation

See Zirh Soothe Gel Post Shave Solution dupes View full product details

O'Douds Apothecary Shave Cream

O'Douds Apothecary

Shave Cream

34%

Low match

Low irritancy

2/3

key actives shared

36%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are shaving products.
Both contain:Butyrospermum parkii butter Glycerin
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasAllantoin
Unlike the original, it hasCocos nucifera oil Ricinus communis seed oil

See O'Douds Apothecary Shave Cream dupes View full product details

James + Jake How Smooth Calming Post Shave Cream

James + Jake

How Smooth Calming Post Shave Cream

30%

Low match

Medium irritancy

2/3

key actives shared

36%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are shaving products.
Both contain:Butyrospermum parkii butter Glycerin
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasAllantoin
Unlike the original, it hasCaprylic/capric triglyceride Cetyl alcohol

See James + Jake How Smooth Calming Post Shave Cream dupes View full product details

Captain's Choice Shave Balm - North

Captain's Choice

Shave Balm - North

22%

Low match

High irritancy

2/3

key actives shared

55%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are shaving products.
Both contain:Butyrospermum parkii butter Glycerin
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasAllantoin
Unlike the original, it hasRetinyl palmitate Peg-12 dimethicone Dimethicone
It also works for:Anti-agingEvens skin tone

See Captain's Choice Shave Balm - North dupes View full product details

MALIN + GOETZ Vitamin E Shaving Cream

MALIN + GOETZ

Vitamin E Shaving Cream

21%

Low match

Medium irritancy

2/3

key actives shared

55%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are shaving products.
Both contain:Butyrospermum parkii butter Glycerin
Both work for:Moisturizing
Unlike the original, it hasPetrolatum Salicylic acid Caprylic/capric triglyceride
It also works for:Anti-blemishExfoliationAnti-aging

See MALIN + GOETZ Vitamin E Shaving Cream dupes View full product details

Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel

Jack Black

Post Shave Cooling Gel

21%

Low match

High irritancy

1/3

key actives shared

64%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are shaving products.
Both contain:Glycerin
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasButyrospermum parkii butter
Unlike the original, it hasImperata cylindrica root extract Peg-12 dimethicone Glyceryl acrylate/acrylic acid copolymer
It also works for:Anti-oxidation

Buy at Bluemercury$22.00 $19.55as of 10/30 06:16 GMT

See Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel dupes View full product details

Bikini Zone Anti-Bump Shave Gel For Sensitive Areas

Bikini Zone

Anti-Bump Shave Gel For Sensitive Areas

20%

Low match

High irritancy

1/3

key actives shared

45%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are shaving products.
Both contain:Glycerin
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasButyrospermum parkii butter
Unlike the original, it hasRetinyl palmitate Sunflower seed oil Lactose
It also works for:Evens skin toneAnti-aging

Buy on Amazon$7.76 · as of 10/31 06:06 GMT

See Bikini Zone Anti-Bump Shave Gel For Sensitive Areas dupes View full product details

Speick Aftershave Balm - Sensitive

Speick

Aftershave Balm - Sensitive

19%

Low match

High irritancy

1/3

key actives shared

36%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are shaving products.
Both contain:Glycerin
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasAllantoin Butyrospermum parkii butter
Unlike the original, it hasPanthenol Caprylic/capric triglyceride Mel

Buy on Amazon$16.99 · as of 10/31 06:15 GMT

See Speick Aftershave Balm - Sensitive dupes View full product details

Saponificio Varesino Aromatic Fern After Shave

Saponificio Varesino

Aromatic Fern After Shave

17%

Low match

High irritancy

1/3

key actives shared

27%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are shaving products.
Both contain:Glycerin
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasAllantoin Butyrospermum parkii butter

See Saponificio Varesino Aromatic Fern After Shave dupes View full product details

Institut Karite Paris Aftershave Balm with Shea Butter

Institut Karite Paris

Aftershave Balm with Shea Butter

12%

Low match

High irritancy

3/3

key actives shared

64%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are shaving products.
Both contain:Allantoin Butyrospermum parkii butter Glycerin
Both work for:Moisturizing
Unlike the original, it hasPrunus amygdalus dulcis oil Peg-12 dimethicone Glyceryl stearate se

See Institut Karite Paris Aftershave Balm with Shea Butter dupes View full product details

Bulldog Original After Shave Balm

Bulldog

Original After Shave Balm

10%

Low match

High irritancy

2/3

key actives shared

55%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are shaving products.
Both contain:Allantoin Glycerin
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasButyrospermum parkii butter
Unlike the original, it hasEthylhexyl palmitate Caprylic/capric triglyceride Sunflower seed oil

See Bulldog Original After Shave Balm dupes View full product details

Andalou Naturals MEN Smooth Glide Shave Cream

Andalou Naturals

MEN Smooth Glide Shave Cream

10%

Low match

High irritancy

2/3

key actives shared

55%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are shaving products.
Both contain:Allantoin Glycerin
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasButyrospermum parkii butter
Unlike the original, it hasPanthenol Cannabis sativa seed oil Cetyl alcohol

Buy on Amazon$5.96 · as of 10/28 12:01 GMT

See Andalou Naturals MEN Smooth Glide Shave Cream dupes View full product details

RITUALS The Ritual of Samurai After Shave Refresh Gel

RITUALS

The Ritual of Samurai After Shave Refresh Gel

10%

Low match

High irritancy

1/3

key actives shared

45%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are shaving products.
Both contain:Glycerin
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasButyrospermum parkii butter
Unlike the original, it hasPanthenol Centella asiatica leaf extract
It also works for:Anti-aging

See RITUALS The Ritual of Samurai After Shave Refresh Gel dupes View full product details

Duke Cannon Supply Co Ice Cold After Shave Balm

Duke Cannon Supply Co

Ice Cold After Shave Balm

8%

Low match

High irritancy

2/3

key actives shared

27%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are shaving products.
Both contain:Butyrospermum parkii butter Glycerin
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasAllantoin
Unlike the original, it hasMethyl gluceth-20 Adansonia digitata seed oil Dimethicone

See Duke Cannon Supply Co Ice Cold After Shave Balm dupes View full product details

Provence Sante Vervain and Linden Shaving Soap

Provence Sante

Vervain and Linden Shaving Soap

8%

Low match

High irritancy

2/3

key actives shared

27%

of the original's ingredients

Why it's a dupe

Both are shaving products.
Both contain:Butyrospermum parkii butter Glycerin
Both work for:Moisturizing
The original also hasAllantoin

Buy at SmallFlower$11.00 Amazon

See Provence Sante Vervain and Linden Shaving Soap dupes View full product details

Affiliate links · As an Amazon Associate, WIMJ earns from qualifying purchases.

About Match %

70%+ - High match

40-69% - Medium match

<40% - Low match

Note: Ingredient concentrations are estimated; products aren't lab-tested. A close match doesn't guarantee the same feel.