What's In My Jar

Dupes & alternatives for Neutrogena-Extra Gentle Eye Makeup Remover Pads

Extra Gentle Eye Makeup Remover Pads
Neutrogena

Extra Gentle Eye Makeup Remover Pads

Medium irritancy Score: 100/100
View Product Search Another
20 alternatives found · Best match: 44% (Medium)
Essential Cleansing Bio Face Wipes Sensitive Skin
Superdrug
Essential Cleansing Bio Face Wipes Sensitive Skin
44%
Medium match
$1.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

PANTHENOLMAGNESIUM ASPARTATEGLYCERIN +4 more

Key differences

COPPER GLUCONATEZINC GLUCONATEPEG-35 CASTOR OIL
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula44%
Active ingredients67%
All ingredients59%
View full product details
Makeup Removing Wipes
PCA SKIN
Makeup Removing Wipes
42%
Medium match
$20.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

CYCLOPENTASILOXANEGLYCERINCETEARYL ALCOHOL +3 more

Key differences

ALTHAEA OFFICINALIS ROOT EXTRACTPOLYSORBATE 20SODIUM LAURYL GLUCOSE CARBOXYLATE +1 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula42%
Active ingredients67%
All ingredients45%
View full product details
Mini GO OFF Makeup Remover Wipes
ONE/SIZE by Patrick Starrr
Mini GO OFF Makeup Remover Wipes
40%
Medium match
Medium irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINCYCLOPENTASILOXANECETEARETH-12 +3 more

Key differences

AVENA SATIVA KERNEL EXTRACTCAPRYLIC/CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDETREHALOSE +8 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula40%
Active ingredients67%
All ingredients55%
View full product details
Go Off Juiciest Makeup Remover Wipes
One/Size
Go Off Juiciest Makeup Remover Wipes
40%
Medium match
$33.00
Medium irritancy

Why it matches

CYCLOPENTASILOXANEGLYCERINGLYCERYL STEARATE +3 more

Key differences

AVENA SATIVA KERNEL EXTRACTCAPRYLIC/CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDEALTHAEA OFFICINALIS ROOT EXTRACT +10 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula40%
Active ingredients67%
All ingredients55%
View full product details
Cheat Sheet Makeup Removing Wipes
Higher Education Skincare
Cheat Sheet Makeup Removing Wipes
38%
Low match
Medium irritancy

Why it matches

CYCLOPENTASILOXANEGLYCERINCETEARYL ALCOHOL +3 more

Key differences

AVENA SATIVA KERNEL EXTRACTALTHAEA OFFICINALIS ROOT EXTRACTPOLYSORBATE 20 +2 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula38%
Active ingredients67%
All ingredients55%
View full product details
Makeup Remover Cleansing Cloths Single Pack
e.l.f. Cosmetics
Makeup Remover Cleansing Cloths Single Pack
38%
Low match
$6.00
Medium irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINCETEARETH-20CETEARYL ALCOHOL +2 more

Key differences

PEG-40 HYDROGENATED CASTOR OILPOLYSORBATE 20XANTHAN GUM
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula38%
Active ingredients67%
All ingredients55%
View full product details
Makeup Removing Wipes
Lancer Skincare
Makeup Removing Wipes
38%
Low match
$32.00
Medium irritancy

Why it matches

CYCLOPENTASILOXANEGLYCERINCETEARYL ALCOHOL +3 more

Key differences

AVENA SATIVA KERNEL EXTRACTALTHAEA OFFICINALIS ROOT EXTRACTPOLYSORBATE 20 +2 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula38%
Active ingredients67%
All ingredients50%
View full product details
Makeup Removing Wipes
KYLIE SKIN
Makeup Removing Wipes
38%
Low match
Medium irritancy

Why it matches

CYCLOPENTASILOXANEGLYCERINCETEARYL ALCOHOL +3 more

Key differences

AVENA SATIVA KERNEL EXTRACTALTHAEA OFFICINALIS ROOT EXTRACTPOLYSORBATE 20 +2 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula38%
Active ingredients67%
All ingredients50%
View full product details
Sugar Rush - Coco-Nuts About You Makeup Removing Biodegradable Wipes
Tarte
Sugar Rush - Coco-Nuts About You Makeup Removing Biodegradable Wipes
37%
Low match
Medium irritancy

Why it matches

PANTHENOLGLYCERINCETEARETH-12 +3 more

Key differences

COCOS NUCIFERA FRUIT EXTRACTSODIUM HYALURONATESORBITAN OLEATE DECYLGLUCOSIDE CROSSPOLYMER
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula37%
Active ingredients67%
All ingredients59%
View full product details
Ultra Calm Cleansing Cream
ALASTIN Skincare
Ultra Calm Cleansing Cream
36%
Low match
$45.00
Low irritancy

Why it matches

PANTHENOLGLYCERINCETEARETH-20 +3 more

Key differences

LINOLEIC ACIDDIMETHICONEBETAINE +10 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula36%
Active ingredients67%
All ingredients50%
View full product details
All About Clean All-in-One Cleansing Micellar Milk + Makeup Remover
Clinique
All About Clean All-in-One Cleansing Micellar Milk + Makeup Remover
36%
Low match
$19.50
Low irritancy

Why it matches

PANTHENOLGLYCERINCETEARETH-20 +2 more

Key differences

ARGININECAPRYLIC/CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDEALGAE EXTRACT +5 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula36%
Active ingredients50%
All ingredients36%
View full product details
Clear Complexion Makeup Remover
Almay
Clear Complexion Makeup Remover
35%
Low match
$4.65
Medium irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINCETEARYL ALCOHOLCETEARETH-12 +2 more

Key differences

SALICYLIC ACIDUREACAMELLIA SINENSIS LEAF EXTRACT +3 more
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula35%
Active ingredients67%
All ingredients45%
View full product details
Bear Naked Wipes Mini
Josie Maran
Bear Naked Wipes Mini
35%
Low match
$12.00
Medium irritancy

Why it matches

GLYCERINCETEARYL ALCOHOLGLYCERYL STEARATE +2 more

Key differences

ARGANIA SPINOSA KERNEL OILALTHAEA OFFICINALIS ROOT EXTRACTPOLYSORBATE 20
View details
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula35%
Active ingredients67%
All ingredients41%
View full product details

About Similarity Scores

Our similarity score compares product formulas based on shared active ingredients, hero ingredients, and overall formula composition. A higher score means a more similar formula.

70%+ - High match
40-69% - Medium match
<40% - Low match

Note: Similarity is based on WIMJ's formula analysis (actives + overall formula similarity). Ingredient concentrations are estimated; products aren't lab-tested. A similar formula doesn't guarantee the same texture or feel.