Grandpa Soap Co.
Pine Tar Bar Soap
30%
Low match
Low irritancy
0/2
key actives shared
40%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- It also works for:Cleansing
Beekman 1802 Heirloom Pear Goat Milk Soap Dupes
We found no close formula dupe for Beekman 1802 Heirloom Pear Goat Milk Soap. The nearest product, Grandpa Soap Co. Pine Tar Bar Soap, is only a 30% match: it shares the original's only key ingredient (Glycerin).
Match % combines shared ingredients, the first five ingredients, shared actives and hero ingredients, irritancy (lower counts in the alternative's favour), texture and body area. Only products in the same routine step are compared.
Beekman 1802
Heirloom Pear Goat Milk Soap
Medium irritancy Score: 75/100
- What it is
- Formula with 1 key ingredient
- Works for
- Moisturizing
20 alternatives found · Best match: 30% (Low)
No close formula dupes found
These are the closest alternatives based on WIMJ's similarity score. Consider filtering by irritancy or ingredients you want to avoid.
Top dupes for Beekman 1802 Heirloom Pear Goat Milk Soap
.png)
28%
Low match
Medium irritancy
1/2
key actives shared
53%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both contain:Glycerin
- Both work for:Moisturizing
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- Unlike the original, it hasGalactoarabinanPrunus amygdalus dulcis oilButyrospermum parkii butter
Soap & Paper Factory
Fig + Honey Bar Soap
28%
Low match
Medium irritancy
1/2
key actives shared
53%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both contain:Glycerin
- Both work for:Moisturizing
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- Unlike the original, it hasButyrospermum parkii butterBorago officinalis seed oilMeadowfoam seed oil
Kala
Coconut Soap
28%
Low match
Low irritancy
1/2
key actives shared
47%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both contain:Glycerin
- Both work for:Moisturizing
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- Unlike the original, it hasCocos nucifera oilCocos nucifera fruit extract
SheaMoisture
Manuka Honey & Mafura Oil Shea Butter Soap
28%
Low match
Low irritancy
1/2
key actives shared
47%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both contain:Glycerin
- Both work for:Moisturizing
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- Unlike the original, it hasAdansonia digitata seed oilHoney
Bioderma
Atoderm Ultra-Rich Soap
28%
Low match
Low irritancy
0/2
key actives shared
40%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- It also works for:Cleansing
Moroccanoil
Body Soap
27%
Low match
Medium irritancy
0/2
key actives shared
40%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- It also works for:Cleansing
Garnier
Pure Active Charcoal Bar
27%
Low match
Medium irritancy
1/2
key actives shared
40%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both contain:Glycerin
- Both work for:Moisturizing
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- Unlike the original, it hasZinc pcasalicylic acid
27%
Low match
Low irritancy
1/2
key actives shared
33%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both contain:Glycerin
- Both work for:Moisturizing
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- Unlike the original, it hasPrunus amygdalus dulcis oil
Thursday Plantation
Tea Tree Skin Care Soap
27%
Low match
Low irritancy
0/2
key actives shared
33%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- It also works for:Cleansing
The Balnea Body Company
Sorbolene Unscented Soap
27%
Low match
Low irritancy
1/2
key actives shared
33%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both contain:Glycerin
- Both work for:Moisturizing
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- Unlike the original, it hasWheat germ oil
Nécessaire
The Body Bar – 2% Physical Exfoliant
27%
Low match
Low irritancy
1/2
key actives shared
33%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both contain:Glycerin
- Both work for:Moisturizing
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- Unlike the original, it hasNiacinamideCeramide apCeramide ag
- It also works for:Anti-agingAnti-blemishEvens skin tone
Asepxia
Soap Scrub Bar Floral
25%
Low match
Medium irritancy
1/2
key actives shared
60%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both contain:Glycerin
- Both work for:Moisturizing
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- Unlike the original, it hasSalicylic acidGlycolic acidAHAs
- It also works for:Anti-blemishExfoliationEvens skin toneAnti-aging
Zest
Bar Soap Aqua
25%
Low match
Medium irritancy
0/2
key actives shared
60%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- It also works for:Cleansing
25%
Low match
Medium irritancy
0/2
key actives shared
47%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- It also works for:Cleansing
Tea Tree Therapy
Vegetable Base Soap
25%
Low match
Medium irritancy
1/2
key actives shared
47%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both contain:Glycerin
- Both work for:Moisturizing
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
Pre de Provence
Sandalwood Soap Bar
25%
Low match
Medium irritancy
0/2
key actives shared
47%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- It also works for:Cleansing
OARS + ALPS
Moisturizing Alps Bar Soap
25%
Low match
Medium irritancy
1/2
key actives shared
47%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- Both contain:Glycerin
- Both work for:Moisturizing
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- Unlike the original, it hasButyrospermum parkii butterGalactoarabinan
25%
Low match
Medium irritancy
0/2
key actives shared
47%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- It also works for:Cleansing
25%
Low match
Medium irritancy
0/2
key actives shared
47%
of the original's ingredients
Why it's a dupe
- The original also hasElaeis guineensis oil
- It also works for:Cleansing
Affiliate links · As an Amazon Associate, WIMJ earns from qualifying purchases.
About Match %
70%+ - High match
40-69% - Medium match
<40% - Low match
Note: Ingredient concentrations are estimated; products aren't lab-tested. A close match doesn't guarantee the same feel.