Grandpa Soap Co.
Pine Tar Bar Soap30%
Low match
$4.59
Low irritancy Why it matches
GLYCERIN
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula30%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients40%
Dupes & alternatives for Beekman 1802-Heirloom Pear Goat Milk Soap
20 alternatives found · Best match: 30% (Low)
No close formula dupes found
These are the closest alternatives based on WIMJ's similarity score. Consider filtering by irritancy or ingredients you want to avoid.
28%
Low match
Medium irritancy
Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERGALACTOARABINAN
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (2)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula28%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients53%
Soap & Paper Factory
Fig + Honey Bar Soap28%
Low match
$8.00
Medium irritancy Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
BORAGO OFFICINALIS SEED OILBUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERLIMNANTHES ALBA SEED OIL
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (3)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula28%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients53%
Kala
Coconut Soap28%
Low match
Low irritancy
Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
COCOS NUCIFERA FRUIT EXTRACTCOCOS NUCIFERA OILCOCOS NUCIFERA OIL +1 more
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (4)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula28%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients47%
Garnier
Pure Active Charcoal Bar27%
Low match
$3.99
Medium irritancy Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
ZINC PCA
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (1)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula27%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients40%
27%
Low match
$12.00
Low irritancy Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
NIACINAMIDECERAMIDE EOPLINOLEIC ACID +8 more
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (11)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula27%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients33%
Thursday Plantation
Tea Tree Skin Care Soap27%
Low match
$4.99
Low irritancy Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
LANOLINTITANIUM DIOXIDEPALM ACID +1 more
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (4)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula27%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients33%
Asepxia
Soap Scrub Bar Floral25%
Low match
$3.99
Medium irritancy Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
SALICYLIC ACIDGLYCOLIC ACIDTITANIUM DIOXIDE
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (3)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula25%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients60%
OARS + ALPS
Moisturizing Alps Bar Soap25%
Low match
$9.95
Medium irritancy Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERGALACTOARABINANKAOLIN
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (3)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula25%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients47%
Institut Karite Paris
Rose Shea Soap25%
Low match
$4.64
Medium irritancy Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
PARAFFINUM LIQUIDUMBUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERCERA MICROCRISTALLINA
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (3)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula25%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients47%
25%
Low match
$5.99
Medium irritancy Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
JOJOBA ESTERSGALACTOARABINANPOTASSIUM STEARATE +7 more
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (10)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula25%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients47%
Tea Tree Therapy
Vegetable Base Soap25%
Low match
$4.49
Medium irritancy Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
TITANIUM DIOXIDE
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (1)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula25%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients47%
25%
Low match
$6.00
Medium irritancy Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTER
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (1)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula25%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients47%
SheaMoisture
Olive & Green Tea Shea Butter Soap25%
Low match
$4.99
Medium irritancy Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERCAMELLIA SINENSIS LEAFPERSEA GRATISSIMA OIL +1 more
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (4)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula25%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients47%
25%
Low match
$7.00
Medium irritancy Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERTITANIUM DIOXIDE
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (2)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula25%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients47%
Nivea
Honey + Oil Bar Soap25%
Low match
$3.95
Medium irritancy Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
GLYCERYL GLUCOSIDESIMMONDSIA CHINENSIS SEED OIL
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (2)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula25%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients40%
Nubian Heritage
Peppermint Aloe Bar Soap25%
Low match
$5.99
Medium irritancy Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERTITANIUM DIOXIDE
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (2)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula25%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients40%
Fenjal
Classic Creme Soap25%
Low match
$5.22
Medium irritancy Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
CAPRYLIC/CAPRIC TRIGLYCERIDETITANIUM DIOXIDETOCOPHEROL +5 more
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (8)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula25%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients40%
25%
Low match
Medium irritancy
Why it matches
GLYCERIN
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula25%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients40%
Baxter of California
Charcoal Clay Deep Cleansing Bar25%
Low match
$36.03
Medium irritancy Why it matches
GLYCERIN
Key differences
KAOLINRICINUS COMMUNIS SEED OILCOCOS NUCIFERA OIL +4 more
View details
Common ingredients (1)
Different ingredients (7)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula25%
Active ingredients75%
All ingredients40%
About Similarity Scores
Our similarity score compares product formulas based on shared active ingredients, hero ingredients, and overall formula composition. A higher score means a more similar formula.
70%+ - High match
40-69% - Medium match
<40% - Low match
Note: Similarity is based on WIMJ's formula analysis (actives + overall formula similarity). Ingredient concentrations are estimated; products aren't lab-tested. A similar formula doesn't guarantee the same texture or feel.