Make-up Cleanser | What's in my jar

I'm very happy with my current routine, I feel like my skin is in good shape (and I'm even getting compliments here and there!) - the only thing I have trouble with is my (make-up) cleanser. I don't wear a lot of make-up, a very light tinted serum on some days, but I do have a waterproof mascara.

I currently have a great cleanser (Niod cleaning ester), but I bought it in London and after Brexit I can't seem to order it online. It's almost empty and I need a replacement. I've tried the Ordinary Squalane and I do like it for make-up free days, but it doesn't seem strong enough for my waterproof mascara. I have dry and sometimes reactive skin, so I enjoy a balmy texture, not foam or anything that feels stripping.

Would the Inkey List Oat cleansing balm work for me? Or any other suggestions?