37%
Low match
$12.00
Medium irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula37%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients67%
Dupes & alternatives for Caswell-Massey-Almond Shave Soap
20 alternatives found ยท Best match: 37% (Low)
No close formula dupes found
These are the closest alternatives based on WIMJ's similarity score. Consider filtering by irritancy or ingredients you want to avoid.
Black Ship Grooming Co.
Grace O'Malley Shave Soap35%
Low match
$9.75
Medium irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
Key differences
BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTER
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Different ingredients (1)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula35%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients67%
Soap Commander
Fortitude Shaving Soap35%
Low match
$17.50
Medium irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
Key differences
BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERRICINUS COMMUNIS SEED OIL
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Different ingredients (2)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula35%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients67%
Myrsol
Shaving Cream35%
Low match
$16.95
Medium irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
Key differences
LANOLIN
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Different ingredients (1)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula35%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients67%
35%
Low match
$9.95
Medium irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
Key differences
HELIANTHUS ANNUUS SEED OIL
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Different ingredients (1)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula35%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients67%
34%
Low match
$10.00
High irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
Key differences
LACTIC ACIDBUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERTHEOBROMA CACAO SEED BUTTER
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Different ingredients (3)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula34%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients89%
Paula's choice
PC4Men Shave Full size34%
Low match
$16.00
Medium irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
Key differences
ALLANTOINCARNOSINE
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula34%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients56%
Tabula Rasa
Patchouli Shaving Soap34%
Low match
$24.50
Low irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
Key differences
ARGANIA SPINOSA KERNEL OILMANGIFERA INDICA SEED BUTTER
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Different ingredients (2)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula34%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients56%
34%
Low match
$62.00
Low irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula34%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients56%
Stirling Soap Co.
Sharp Dressed Man Shave Soap33%
Low match
$13.95
Medium irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
Key differences
LANOLINBUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERRICINUS COMMUNIS SEED OIL +1 more
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Different ingredients (4)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula33%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients67%
Baume.Be
Shaving Cream33%
Low match
Medium irritancy
Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
Key differences
BUTYROSPERMUM PARKII BUTTERGLYCINE SOJA OIL
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Different ingredients (2)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula33%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients67%
Noble Otter
Neon Sun Shave Soap33%
Low match
$20.00
Medium irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILCOCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
Key differences
LANOLINMANGIFERA INDICA SEED BUTTERPERSEA GRATISSIMA OIL +4 more
View details
Common ingredients (3)
Different ingredients (7)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula33%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients67%
Ach Brito
Shaving Cream32%
Low match
$8.50
High irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
Key differences
AVENA SATIVA KERNEL EXTRACTLANOLIN
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Different ingredients (2)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula32%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients89%
32%
Low match
$5.95
High irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula32%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients67%
Meissner Tremonia
Salty Sea Sage Shaving Cream32%
Low match
$24.50
Medium irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
Key differences
KAOLINSIMMONDSIA CHINENSIS SEED OIL
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Different ingredients (2)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula32%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients56%
30%
Low match
$6.50
High irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
Key differences
PANTHENOLDIMETHICONE
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Different ingredients (2)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula30%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients67%
Wilkinson Sword
Vintage Shaving Soap30%
Low match
$3.59
High irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
Key differences
DIMETHICONE
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Different ingredients (1)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula30%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients67%
Blind Barber
Watermint Gin Shave Cream30%
Low match
$16.00
High irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
Key differences
PANTHENOLJOJOBA ESTERS
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Different ingredients (2)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula30%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients67%
Taylor of Old Bond Street
Lime Zest Shaving Cream Bowl30%
Low match
$16.99
High irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
View details
Common ingredients (2)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula30%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients67%
Spa Ceylon
Frankincense Shaving Cream30%
Low match
$13.95
High irritancy Why it matches
COCOS NUCIFERA OILCOCOS NUCIFERA OILGLYCERIN
Key differences
TOCOPHEROL
View details
Common ingredients (3)
Different ingredients (1)
Similarity breakdown
Overall formula30%
Active ingredients100%
All ingredients67%
About Similarity Scores
Our similarity score compares product formulas based on shared active ingredients, hero ingredients, and overall formula composition. A higher score means a more similar formula.
70%+ - High match
40-69% - Medium match
<40% - Low match
Note: Similarity is based on WIMJ's formula analysis (actives + overall formula similarity). Ingredient concentrations are estimated; products aren't lab-tested. A similar formula doesn't guarantee the same texture or feel.