Dupes & alternatives for ARTOIS - ATVT Panthenol V-shield Skin Toner

	ARTOIS - ATVT Panthenol V-shield Skin Toner	PYUNKANG YUL - Black Tea Deep Infusion Toner Sponsored	PYUNKANG YUL - Black Tea Deep Infusion Toner	MISSHA - Vita C Plus Brightening Toner	JAYJUN - OKRA PHYTO MUCIN DEEP ACTIVATING CREAM TONER	su:m37 - Summa Elixir 8-Miracle Power Essence Jumbo	MEDI-PEEL - V-Perfect Shape Lifting Mist	The History of Whoo - Bichup Self-Generating Anti-Aging Essence	DERMAFIRM - Moist Barrier Boosting Toner M4	TOSOWOONG - Ceramide Toner	LABIOTTE - Collagen Full Up Treatment Essence	NATURE REPUBLIC - Hyathenol Hydra Toner
Price
WIMJ similarity score		53%	53%	50%	50%	49%	49%	48%	48%	48%	48%	48%
Key ingredients	ceramide np panthenol +8 more	Common: acetyl hexapeptide-8 panthenol +3 more Other: niacinamide madecassoside +19 more	Common: acetyl hexapeptide-8 panthenol +3 more Other: niacinamide madecassoside +19 more	Common: panthenol acetyl hexapeptide-8 +4 more Other: lactobionic acid niacinamide +21 more	Common: panthenol acetyl hexapeptide-8 +3 more Other: acetyl tetrapeptide-3 acetyl tetrapeptide-2 +18 more	Common: panthenol ceramide np +4 more Other: niacinamide adenosine +26 more	Common: panthenol acetyl hexapeptide-8 +4 more Other: sh-octapeptide-4 acetyl dipeptide-1 cetyl ester +21 more	Common: ceramide np acetyl hexapeptide-8 +4 more Other: oligopeptide-1 niacinamide +26 more	Common: ceramide np panthenol +4 more Other: gluconolactone phytosphingosine +12 more	Common: ceramide np panthenol +4 more Other: niacinamide madecassoside +18 more	Common: panthenol ceramide np +3 more Other: niacinamide adenosine +16 more	Common: ceramide np panthenol +2 more Other: niacinamide dipeptide-2 +6 more
Irritancy	IRRITANCY HIGH	IRRITANCY MEDIUM	IRRITANCY MEDIUM	IRRITANCY HIGH	IRRITANCY MEDIUM	IRRITANCY HIGH	IRRITANCY HIGH	IRRITANCY HIGH	IRRITANCY MEDIUM	IRRITANCY MEDIUM	IRRITANCY MEDIUM	IRRITANCY MEDIUM
Potential Irritants	limonene Has skin benefit? citral Has skin benefit? +16 more	gardenia florida fruit extract Has skin benefit? scutellaria baicalensis root extract Has skin benefit? +25 more	gardenia florida fruit extract Has skin benefit? scutellaria baicalensis root extract Has skin benefit? +25 more	lavandula angustifolia oil Has skin benefit? eucalyptus globulus leaf oil Has skin benefit? +23 more	betula alba bark extract Has skin benefit? artemisia vulgaris extract Has skin benefit? +10 more	geraniol Has skin benefit? citronellol Has skin benefit? +63 more	chamomilla recutita flower extract Has skin benefit? rosmarinus officinalis leaf extract Has skin benefit? +21 more	parfum Has skin benefit? ci 19140 Has skin benefit? +18 more	oleic acid Has skin benefit? glyceryl acrylate/acrylic acid copolymer Has skin benefit? +12 more	vanilla planifolia fruit extract Has skin benefit? jasminum officinale flower water Has skin benefit? +16 more	parfum Has skin benefit? arctium lappa root extract Has skin benefit? +25 more	chamomilla recutita flower extract Has skin benefit? hibiscus esculentus fruit extract Has skin benefit? +12 more
All ingredients	water Has skin benefit? panthenol Has skin benefit? +42 more	water Has skin benefit? butylene glycol Has skin benefit? +72 more	water Has skin benefit? butylene glycol Has skin benefit? +72 more	water Has skin benefit? glycerin Has skin benefit? +57 more	water Has skin benefit? butylene glycol Has skin benefit? +45 more	water Has skin benefit? 2,3-butanediol Has skin benefit? +182 more	water Has skin benefit? alcohol Has skin benefit? +61 more	water Has skin benefit? glycerin Has skin benefit? +94 more	water Has skin benefit? glycerin Has skin benefit? +34 more	water Has skin benefit? dipropylene glycol Has skin benefit? +55 more	water Has skin benefit? methylpropanediol Has skin benefit? +72 more	water Has skin benefit? butylene glycol Has skin benefit? +40 more