How well do the ingredients match what the product promises?
Filter by how likely the formula is to cause irritation.
Exclude common irritants and allergens from your results.
The fragrance is a nice light minty scent. I quite like it. The foaming depends on how much you use, and the removal of makeup depends on if you use a face cloth or how long you rub. I don't wear makeup daily, so I'll let you know next time I use it.
Only con is that it is messy, it is charcoal so it's a muddy grey colour