How well do the ingredients match what the product promises?
Filter by how likely the formula is to cause irritation.
Exclude common irritants and allergens from your results.
I use it once a week as a mask overnight to help restore moisture and fade post-acne marks, usually the night after I do my harshest acne treatment. This helps me avoid irritation - but you cannot layer it overtop anything because its such a thick occlusive and can easily trap bacteria or cause an active to be overly effective/irritating. I only use it once a week because it can cause milia to form. It is safe for sensitive skin and fungal acne in moderation, and more restoring than vaseline. If you're not a back sleeper it will get all over your pillowcase but won't stain it or anything.
This is the only thing that works to keep my very dry skin happy in the winter. It moisturizes my skin and hugs my hydrating products in like nothing else. If I apply a thin layer on my face ~5 times a week, my skin tightness/itchyness due to dry weather goes away almost completely. For the rest on my body, I can use it several times a day with no issues. I no longer get cracked and itchy hands and lips in the winter (plus, I've noticed a substantial increase in the fullness of my lips)! It works very well for healing cuts and wind-burn quickly.
The biggest downside is that I cannot use it on my face everyday, or else I WILL begin to get clogged pores. As a slightly acne prone person, I can use a very thin layer about 5x a week on my face. More acne-prone people might need to be more careful. It is also very thick and hard to spread over a large area, so I rarely use it all over my arms/legs (even though they get very dry too). It tends to leave a fairly shiny finish too, although it (mostly) disappears within an hour or two.
Compared to other similar products, I find that this product breaks me out a little bit less than plain Vaseline, and works far better for plumping my lips. I have heard that the CeraVe healing ointment is another good alternative, but I haven't tried it yet.
Aquaphor has been a life-saver when it comes to maintaining moisturization in my skin's barrier. It can be heavy, so if you break out easily and have oily-skin, I do not recommend this product.
It's a really good product to use for moisturizing. The 'finish' depends on just how much you use.